Bill banning transgender service members proposed to Congress

GEAR CHECK: Our readers don't just follow the news - they stay ready. Featured gear from this story is below.

Staff Writer

A bill proposing to prohibit transgender people from serving in the military has been introduced in Congress, causing concern amongst members of the community who have already experienced several policy reversals.

Introduced by Republican Senator Marco Rubio and Republican Representative Jim Banks, the “Ensuring Military Readiness Act” is unlikely to pass the Democratic-controlled Senate, but advocates worry it represents a future specter of policy reversal for transgender people. Republicans are also likely to propose amendments on the issue during the annual defense policy bill later this year.

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Congress should start by passing the bipartisan bill I introduced last October that would protect transgender members of the U.S. military by preventing DoD from removing currently serving members of the Armed Forces based solely on their gender identity.</p>&mdash; House Armed Services Democrats (@HASCDemocrats) <a href="https://twitter.com/HASCDemocrats/status/977365523380953089?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">March 24, 2018</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

Transgender service members and veterans have voiced concerns that policy changes over the past six years, including the Trump-era ban, the Biden administration revoking it and the new legislation, have taken a toll on their financial stability, mental wellness, and long-term planning.

Additionally, banning transgender people from serving in the military, who are around twice as likely as the general population to have served, would exclude a critical population from enlisting when recruitment goals are already a challenge for the armed forces.

The Palm Center’s research (a think tank that focuses on LGBTQ+ military issues) from 2020 concluded that the Trump-era ban harmed military readiness by impeding recruitment, retention, cohesion and morale in the military, in addition to hurting the military’s reputation.

Those who support the proposed ban argue that the issue is discouraging many potential recruits from enlisting, while conservatives criticize it as one of many unneeded diversity initiatives However, transgender people are about twice as likely as the general population to have served in the military, so the ban would exclude a critical population from enlisting when the armed forces are consistently struggling to meet recruitment goals.

With estimates placing the number of transgender people serving in the military at around 15,000 as of 2018, the military remains the largest employer of transgender people in the country. The proposed ban threatens troops’ economic stability and freedom to pursue their plans, as they could be prohibited from serving in the military if a conservative Republican captures the White House in 2024 and uses executive action to re-impose the ban.

Transgender service members and veterans, however, note the benefits they offer the military, including diversity of perspectives.

“There are no negative impacts to our deployability, and the diversity that we bring brings increased readiness and increased lethality,” said Alleria Stanley, a 20-year Army veteran who currently serves as director of communications at SPARTA, a transgender military advocacy organization. “By our diversity, we increase additional ideas, perspectives and insights from our unique points of view.”

 

You may also like

Blog

The Army produced nearly 10,000 augmented-reality headsets intended to give troops an advantage in combat. Instead, the equipment is heading into storage after failing to meet soldiers’ needs.
An Army sentinel ordered visitors to maintain silence and respect at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier. The next day, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth personally awarded him a military medal.
A Long Island man built a reputation around an extraordinary military story. Prosecutors say the story was false, and that he later stole more than $81,000 from the veteran’s organization that trusted him with its finances.
Commercial ships are not legally required to seek Houthi permission to cross the Red Sea. But some operators are reportedly emailing a Houthi-run center for assurances that their vessels will not be targeted.
More than 3,200 people were on Citibank’s Tampa-area campus when a gunman opened fire. Within minutes, an armed security officer confronted him inside the building.

Like This Story? Check Out What Our Community Is Buying

Our best sellers are designed for real-world use - not hype.

View Best Sellers