Two EMS workers plead "not guilty" to murder charges

GEAR CHECK: Our readers don't just follow the news - they stay ready. Featured gear from this story is below.

Daniel Sharp

On Friday afternoon, Peter J. Cadigan, 50, and Peggy J. Finley, 44, pleaded "not guilty" to murder in the death of Earl Moore, Jr., 35.

On Friday afternoon, Peter J. Cadigan, 50, and Peggy J. Finley, 44, pleaded "not guilty" to murder in the death of Earl Moore, Jr., 35.

The two Illinois EMS workers were were accused of murder after strapping their patient facedown on a stretcher. The caller, Earl Moore Jr., was reportedly suffering from withdraws and unable to walk when he was put on a stretcher. Moore then suffered asphyxiation while being transported in the prone position. A coroner classified his death as a homicide resulting from the unusual actions taken by the EMS workers to transport Moore Jr. facedown. 

Body cam footage of the call can be seen here:

<iframe width="904" height="509" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/7X4Pz9Msgk0" title="SA Redaction Officer 1" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; web-share" allowfullscreen></iframe>

It is unclear if this was the crew’s first interaction with Moore, or if he was known as a “frequent flyer.” This being slang for a patient EMS crews routinely are called to provide assistance for.

However, the footage prompted the family of Moore to file a civil lawsuit against the workers, and the ambulance company they worked for. The family claiming there was a distinct “lack of humanity” in the way Moore was treated by all responders present. 

In the video, one the responders can be heard saying, “I’m seriously not in the mood for this dumb sh*t tonight.”

At the end of an alternate body camera recording, one of the responders can be heard saying “Aw he strapped him in good and tight. He ain’t going nowhere.”

(Sangamon County Sheriff’s Dept.)

Why call 911?

Earl Moore Jr. called 911 reporting that he saw people ‘inside’ with guns. Three Springfield, Illinois officers were dispatched to respond to the situation. Upon arrival, they were told Moore was experiencing a hallucinatory episode by a bystander. 

Finley and Cadigan, the EMS workers, were called by Springfield Police to transport Moore to a hospital. They then proceeded to put Moore Jr. facedown on a stretcher after carrying him from his residence. 

In case you missed it: A quick guide to VA dental and vision insurance

Autopsy

Asphyxiation was the cause of death, but Earl Moore Jr. was also found to have rib fractures, and cuts on his knees, fingers, and foot as well. The full autopsy can be found here

You may also like

Blog

A deadly Los Angeles bus crash had already killed two people when a second tragedy unfolded just blocks away. A news helicopter covering the first crash suddenly lost altitude and plunged from the sky, killing a reporter, her pilot and a man on the ground.
The Department of Veterans Affairs is putting a record $1.17 billion behind a problem that still affects thousands of Americans who once wore the uniform. The money will go to 680 organizations nationwide to help homeless Veterans and those at immediate risk of losing their homes. The funding comes after the VA housed 51,936 homeless Veterans in fiscal year 2025, its highest total in seven years.
About 90 sailors aboard the USS Kearsarge returned to Naval Station Norfolk after 10 days at sea, only to discover their cars had been towed. The vehicles had been left in a fenced lot near Pier 14 during a base concert, leaving sailors waiting for hours at the impound lot to get them back.
What started with cars spinning donuts in a Houston parking lot ended with a vehicle flipping repeatedly, one person dead, three hospitalized and firearms discovered inside. Five people were in the fleeing vehicle, most or all believed to be juveniles. But the biggest question remained unanswered: who was behind the wheel?
A Russian drone struck a passenger train near Ukraine’s border with Poland just minutes after a diplomatic train carrying Boris Johnson and other senior European figures had passed through the same area.

Like This Story? Check Out What Our Community Is Buying

Our best sellers are designed for real-world use - not hype.

View Best Sellers